User Experience for AI Features

AI features are probabilistic. They'll be wrong sometimes. Great UX design accounts for this uncertainty.

The Uncertainty Problem

Traditional software: User clicks button → Expected result happens

AI software: User provides input → One of many possible outputs happens

Users don't understand this. They expect AI to be right every time.

UX Principles for AI Features

Principle 1: Set Expectations

Tell users what AI can and can't do.

Before interaction:

"AI-powered suggestions based on your preferences.
Results may vary—you can always customize."

During interaction:

"Generating suggestions... (AI suggestions are starting points, not final answers)"

Bad examples:

• "AI knows exactly what you need"
• "Perfect recommendations every time"
• No indication that AI is involved

Principle 2: Show Confidence

Let users know when AI is uncertain.

Confidence Level	UX Pattern
High (>90%)	Show result directly
Medium (70-90%)	Show result + "Did we get this right?"
Low (<70%)	Show options, ask user to choose

Examples:

High confidence email categorization:

✓ Marked as "Work - Project Alpha"

Medium confidence:

Filed under "Work - Project Alpha" — Not right? [Move to different folder]

Low confidence:

We're not sure where this belongs. Choose a folder:

• Work - Project Alpha
• Work - Project Beta
• Personal

Principle 3: Make Correction Easy

Users need to fix AI mistakes without friction.

Good correction patterns:

• One-click to change
• Inline editing
• "Not helpful" feedback button
• Undo immediately available

Bad patterns:

• Multiple steps to correct
• No way to provide feedback
• Can't undo AI actions
• Hidden correction options

Principle 4: Explain When Needed

Users trust what they understand.

Explanation Level	When to Use
None	Low-stakes, high-accuracy features
Brief	Medium stakes ("Based on your history")
Detailed	High stakes, user requests, or errors

Example: Loan application AI

Brief (default):

"Application approved based on your credit profile."

Detailed (on request):

"Your application was approved because:

• Credit score: 750 (Good)
• Income to debt ratio: 25% (Healthy)
• Employment history: 5+ years (Stable)"

Principle 5: Preserve User Control

AI should augment decisions, not make them.

Control Pattern	Example
Suggestions	"You might like..." (user chooses)
Defaults	Pre-filled but editable
Automation with override	"Auto-filed, tap to change"
Confirmation required	"AI suggests deleting. Confirm?"

Error State Design

AI will fail. Plan for it.

Error Types and Responses

Error Type	User Message	Recovery Action
Wrong prediction	"Not what you expected?"	Easy correction + feedback
No prediction possible	"We couldn't analyze this"	Manual alternative
System error	"Something went wrong"	Retry + fallback
Slow response	"Still thinking..."	Loading state + timeout

Error Message Best Practices

Do:

• Acknowledge the limitation
• Provide alternatives
• Make it easy to proceed

Don't:

• Blame the user
• Use technical jargon
• Leave user stuck

Example - Bad:

"Error: Model inference failed with confidence below threshold"

Example - Good:

"We couldn't find a good match. Try:

• Adjusting your search terms
• Browsing categories manually [Search again] [Browse categories]"

Building Feedback Loops

Feedback improves AI over time. Design for it.

Implicit Feedback

Track user behavior without asking:

Signal	What It Means
User accepts suggestion	AI was helpful
User ignores suggestion	AI was irrelevant
User corrects suggestion	AI was wrong
User undoes AI action	AI made a mistake

Explicit Feedback

Ask users directly (sparingly):

Pattern	When to Use
Thumbs up/down	Quick, low friction
"Was this helpful?"	After AI interaction completes
Short survey	Periodically, not every time
"Report a problem"	Always available but not prominent

Feedback UX Guidelines

• Ask at the right moment (after task completion)
• Make it optional
• Show that feedback helps ("Thanks! This helps us improve")
• Don't ask too often (survey fatigue)

Trust-Building Patterns

Progressive Disclosure

Start with AI assistance, let users go deeper:

Level 1: AI suggestion shown
Level 2: "Why?" reveals brief explanation
Level 3: "Learn more" shows detailed reasoning

Transparency Indicators

Show that AI is involved:

• "AI-powered" badge
• "Suggested by AI" label
• Different visual styling for AI content
• "Generated" vs "Verified" distinctions

Building Trust Over Time

Stage	User Mindset	Design Approach
New user	Skeptical	Show more explanations
Returning user	Testing	Track accuracy, show improvements
Power user	Trusting	Reduce friction, more automation

Key Takeaway

Design AI features for imperfection. Set expectations, show confidence levels, make correction easy, and build feedback loops. Users will trust AI that's honest about its limitations.

---

Next: A/B testing AI features comes with unique challenges. Let's explore them. :::