To upgrade Postgres 17 to 18 without downtime, run `pg_createsubscriber` on a physical standby to convert it into a logical subscriber, then `pg_upgrade` that subscriber to Postgres 18.3 while the old primary keeps taking writes. Logical replication catches the new cluster up, you sync sequences manually, and traffic cuts over in seconds instead of minutes.[^1][^2] The classical `pg_upgrade` path is fast — usually a few minutes for a small cluster — but it still requires the old cluster to be **shut down** while it runs.[^3] For an application that pages support at the first 30-second blip, "a few minutes" is not zero. PostgreSQL 18.3 (released February 26, 2026)[^4] makes the zero-downtime path dramatically easier than it used to be by polishing `pg_createsubscriber`, the binary that converts a physical streaming standby into a logical subscriber in one shot. This tutorial walks through the full flow with Docker Compose, ending on a Postgres 18.3 cluster that started life as a Postgres 17.9 primary. ## TL;DR You will run a Postgres 17.9 primary in Docker, attach a streaming physical standby, convert that standby into a logical subscriber with `pg_createsubscriber --all` (a flag new in PG 18[^5]), `pg_upgrade` it to Postgres 18.3, sync sequences, and cut traffic over. Total writeable-downtime: a single connection switch, typically under one second. Every command and version pin in this tutorial was verified against `postgresql.org` docs and Docker Hub on May 13, 2026. ## What you'll learn - Why `pg_upgrade` on its own can't deliver zero downtime, and what the `pg_createsubscriber` + `pg_upgrade` combination changes. - How to configure Postgres 17.9 for logical replication and add a streaming physical standby in Docker. - How to run `pg_createsubscriber --all` to convert that standby into a logical subscriber, including the GUC prerequisites. - How to `pg_upgrade` the new subscriber to Postgres 18.3 while the publisher keeps serving writes. - How to handle sequences — the one piece of state logical replication does **not** carry — without colliding with the publisher's IDs. - How to verify replication is caught up via `pg_subscription_rel`, then perform the cutover. - Five common failure modes and a clean rollback plan. ## Prerequisites - Docker 27.0 or later with Compose v2 (bundled in Docker Desktop and modern Docker Engine packages).[^6] - A POSIX shell (bash or zsh). - Comfort with SQL and Postgres replication terms (publisher, subscriber, replication slot). - Free TCP ports 5532, 5533, and 5534 on `localhost`. Ports are deliberately offset from 5432 to avoid collisions with a developer's existing Postgres. - Roughly 2 GB of free disk for the Docker volumes used in this walkthrough. ## Why pg_upgrade alone leaves a downtime gap `pg_upgrade` rewrites system catalogs and (with `--link`) hardlinks data files into the new cluster, which is why it is fast.[^3] But the old cluster has to be stopped before `pg_upgrade` runs, and the new cluster is not started until `pg_upgrade` finishes. During that window — minutes for a small database, much longer for a large one — every write is rejected. Add the time to drain connections, run analyze on the new cluster, and warm caches, and "a few minutes" frequently turns into a real maintenance window. Logical replication sidesteps the problem because **publisher and subscriber may run different major versions** at the same time.[^7] You build a Postgres 18.3 replica that follows your Postgres 17.9 primary, wait for it to catch up, then cut over. The only downtime is the connection switch. ## The pg_createsubscriber and pg_upgrade workflow Pre-PG 17, the zero-downtime upgrade dance involved `pg_dump --schema-only`, manual `CREATE PUBLICATION` and `CREATE SUBSCRIPTION` statements, and waiting for the initial COPY to finish — a process that took hours on a multi-terabyte database because every row had to be re-copied across the wire. PostgreSQL 17 introduced `pg_createsubscriber` to skip that copy step entirely: it takes an existing **physical** streaming standby (already a byte-for-byte clone of the primary) and converts it into a **logical** subscriber by stopping it, recording an LSN, creating publications and subscriptions, and rewinding the apply position to that LSN.[^8] The binary does not copy any data; it only flips the replication mode. PostgreSQL 18 added three useful flags on top: `--all` (handle every user database in one invocation), `--clean` (drop publications carried over from a previous run), and `--enable-two-phase` (turn on 2PC support).[^5] The `--all` flag is the one that matters most for upgrades, because production clusters rarely have a single database. Combine `pg_createsubscriber` with `pg_upgrade` and the path looks like this: 1. Stand up a streaming physical standby of the existing PG 17 primary. 2. Stop the standby cleanly. 3. Run `pg_createsubscriber --all` against the standby's data directory using PG 17 binaries. 4. Run `pg_upgrade` on the standby's data directory to convert PG 17 → PG 18.3. 5. Start the new PG 18.3 instance; logical replication resumes from the recorded LSN and catches up everything the publisher accepted while the upgrade ran. 6. Sync sequences, cut traffic over, drop the publications on the old primary. ## Step 1: Bring up the Postgres 17.9 publisher Create a project directory and drop in a `docker-compose.yml`: ```yaml # docker-compose.yml name: pg18-zdt services: publisher: image: postgres:17.9 container_name: pg17-publisher ports: - "5532:5432" environment: POSTGRES_PASSWORD: dev POSTGRES_DB: shop volumes: - publisher_data:/var/lib/postgresql/data command: - "postgres" - "-c" - "wal_level=logical" - "-c" - "max_wal_senders=10" - "-c" - "max_replication_slots=10" - "-c" - "listen_addresses=*" volumes: publisher_data: ``` Three settings matter: - `wal_level=logical` writes the extra information the logical decoder needs.[^9] In Postgres 18 you can leave the configured `wal_level` at `replica` and the *effective* level auto-promotes the moment the first logical slot is created;[^10] for PG 17 you still need to set it explicitly and restart, which is why we hard-code it here. - `max_wal_senders=10` and `max_replication_slots=10` are the defaults but worth being explicit about. `pg_createsubscriber` needs at least one slot per database, plus headroom for any existing physical replicas.[^11] Bring it up and seed a tiny data set: ```bash docker compose up -d publisher docker exec -i pg17-publisher psql -U postgres -d shop <<'SQL' CREATE TABLE products ( id bigint GENERATED ALWAYS AS IDENTITY PRIMARY KEY, sku text NOT NULL UNIQUE, price_eur numeric(10,2) NOT NULL, created_at timestamptz NOT NULL DEFAULT now() ); INSERT INTO products (sku, price_eur) VALUES ('NRD-001', 19.99), ('NRD-002', 29.50), ('NRD-003', 9.00); CREATE USER replicator WITH REPLICATION ENCRYPTED PASSWORD 'replpw'; SQL ``` Open `pg_hba.conf` to allow the replication connection from the standby and reload: ```bash docker exec pg17-publisher bash -c "echo 'host replication replicator 0.0.0.0/0 scram-sha-256' >> /var/lib/postgresql/data/pg_hba.conf" docker exec pg17-publisher psql -U postgres -c "SELECT pg_reload_conf();" ``` In production you would scope that CIDR to the standby's actual address. For a localhost demo, `0.0.0.0/0` plus a SCRAM password is fine. ## Step 2: Add a streaming physical standby Run `pg_basebackup` from a fresh PG 17.9 container into a named Docker volume, then start a second Postgres on that volume: ```bash docker volume create pg18-zdt_standby_data docker run --rm --network pg18-zdt_default \ -v pg18-zdt_standby_data:/var/lib/postgresql/data \ -e PGPASSWORD=replpw \ postgres:17.9 \ pg_basebackup -h publisher -p 5432 -U replicator \ -D /var/lib/postgresql/data \ -Fp -R -X stream -P ``` The flags do meaningful work: - `-Fp` writes a plain-format directory tree (required by `pg_createsubscriber`, which works on a real `PGDATA`).[^12] - `-R` writes `standby.signal` and a `primary_conninfo` line into `postgresql.auto.conf`, so the recipient comes up as a streaming standby with no extra config.[^12] - `-X stream` streams WAL alongside the base backup so the data directory is consistent the moment the command exits. Now start the standby on its own port: ```yaml standby: image: postgres:17.9 container_name: pg17-standby ports: - "5533:5432" volumes: - standby_data:/var/lib/postgresql/data command: ["postgres", "-c", "listen_addresses=*"] volumes: publisher_data: standby_data: external: true name: pg18-zdt_standby_data ``` Append the `standby` service to `docker-compose.yml` and the `standby_data` volume entry, then `docker compose up -d standby`. Confirm streaming replication is healthy from the publisher: ```bash docker exec pg17-publisher psql -U postgres -c \ "SELECT application_name, state, sync_state FROM pg_stat_replication;" ``` You should see one row in `streaming` state. Insert a row on the publisher and read it back from port 5533 to confirm replay is live. ## Step 3: Convert the standby with pg_createsubscriber --all `pg_createsubscriber` requires the target server to be **shut down** before it runs.[^1] Stop the standby cleanly, then invoke the binary using a one-shot PG 17.9 container that mounts the same data volume: ```bash docker compose stop standby docker run --rm --network pg18-zdt_default \ -v pg18-zdt_standby_data:/var/lib/postgresql/data \ -e PGPASSWORD=dev \ postgres:17.9 \ pg_createsubscriber --all \ -D /var/lib/postgresql/data \ -P "host=publisher port=5432 user=postgres dbname=postgres" \ -p 5432 \ --verbose ``` `--all` tells the binary to discover every user database on the standby and create a publication/subscription pair for each one — the new PG 18 ergonomics that replaces hand-listing each database with `-d`.[^5] The slot names follow the documented `pg_createsubscriber__` convention so they don't collide with any slots you already have.[^13] Behind the scenes the binary does six things:[^1] 1. Verifies prerequisites: the source must have `wal_level = logical`, `max_replication_slots` and `max_wal_senders` high enough, and the target must have `max_active_replication_origins`, `max_logical_replication_workers`, and `max_worker_processes` high enough. 2. Creates a `FOR ALL TABLES` publication on the source for each database. 3. Creates a logical replication slot on the source for each database. 4. Writes recovery parameters into the target's data dir setting `recovery_target_lsn` and `recovery_target_action = promote`. 5. Restarts the target briefly so it replays up to that LSN and promotes. 6. Creates the matching subscription on the target — without copying initial data, because the physical replica already has it. When the binary exits, restart the standby container: ```bash docker compose start standby docker exec pg17-standby psql -U postgres -d shop \ -c "SELECT subname, subenabled FROM pg_subscription;" ``` You should see `pg_createsubscriber__` listed, with `subenabled = t`. The standby is now a Postgres 17.9 logical subscriber. ## Step 4: pg_upgrade the standby to Postgres 18.3 The next step is a standard `pg_upgrade` from PG 17.9 to PG 18.3, with a critical pre-step: **disable subscriptions on the subscriber before running pg_upgrade**, per the official upgrade docs.[^14] If you skip this step, the upgrade refuses to migrate the subscription state. ```bash docker exec pg17-standby psql -U postgres -d shop \ -c "ALTER SUBSCRIPTION pg_createsubscriber_5_ DISABLE;" docker compose stop standby ``` Replace `` with the actual suffix from `pg_subscription`. With `--all`, you'll have one subscription per user database — disable each one. `pg_upgrade` requires both the old and the new PostgreSQL binaries to be available on the same host. Neither the official `postgres:17.9` nor `postgres:18.3` Docker image ships both versions, so we build a tiny dual-version image. Drop this `Dockerfile.upgrade` next to the compose file: ```dockerfile # Dockerfile.upgrade FROM postgres:18.3-bookworm RUN apt-get update \ && apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends postgresql-17 \ && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/* ``` The PGDG repository configured inside the official `postgres:18.3-bookworm` image already serves every supported major version,[^19] so adding the `postgresql-17` package gives us `/usr/lib/postgresql/17/bin/` alongside `/usr/lib/postgresql/18/bin/` in the same image. Build it once: ```bash docker build -t pg-upgrade:17-to-18 -f Dockerfile.upgrade . ``` Now run `pg_upgrade` against the standby's data directory. Note that PostgreSQL 18 changed the default `PGDATA` location for its Docker image — it now lives at `/var/lib/postgresql/18/docker` so that future major-version upgrades can mount one shared volume.[^20] We follow the same convention here, telling `pg_upgrade` to write the new cluster into `/var/lib/postgresql/18/docker`. The script runs as root so it can `chown` the freshly mounted volume, then drops to the `postgres` user via `gosu` (already installed in the official image) for the actual Postgres operations: ```bash docker volume create pg18-zdt_subscriber_v18 docker run --rm --network pg18-zdt_default \ -v pg18-zdt_standby_data:/var/lib/postgresql/data \ -v pg18-zdt_subscriber_v18:/var/lib/postgresql/18 \ pg-upgrade:17-to-18 bash -c ' chown -R postgres:postgres /var/lib/postgresql/18 && gosu postgres /usr/lib/postgresql/18/bin/initdb \ -D /var/lib/postgresql/18/docker \ -U postgres --auth-local=trust --auth-host=scram-sha-256 && printf "wal_level = logical\nmax_replication_slots = 10\nmax_active_replication_origins = 10\n" \ | gosu postgres tee -a /var/lib/postgresql/18/docker/postgresql.conf && cd /tmp && gosu postgres /usr/lib/postgresql/18/bin/pg_upgrade \ --old-bindir=/usr/lib/postgresql/17/bin \ --new-bindir=/usr/lib/postgresql/18/bin \ --old-datadir=/var/lib/postgresql/data \ --new-datadir=/var/lib/postgresql/18/docker \ --link ' ``` Three things to notice: - `--link` hardlinks the data files into the new cluster, which is why `pg_upgrade` is fast even on large clusters. You cannot start the old PG 17 cluster after a `--link` upgrade completes, so the standby is now permanently a Postgres 18 instance. - The `printf | tee` line writes the three GUCs that `pg_upgrade` checks before it will migrate logical slots — the new cluster needs `wal_level = logical` and `max_replication_slots` at least as large as the old cluster's slot count.[^14] - The publisher keeps accepting writes the entire time `pg_upgrade` runs — those changes will replay through the existing logical slot the moment the upgraded cluster comes up. Add the upgraded cluster to your compose file. Set `PGDATA` explicitly so the official entrypoint discovers the data directory at the new PG 18 location, and pin the GUCs that the upgrade flagged: ```yaml subscriber_v18: image: postgres:18.3 container_name: pg18-subscriber ports: - "5534:5432" environment: PGDATA: /var/lib/postgresql/18/docker volumes: - subscriber_v18:/var/lib/postgresql/18 command: - "postgres" - "-c" - "wal_level=logical" - "-c" - "max_replication_slots=10" - "-c" - "max_active_replication_origins=10" - "-c" - "listen_addresses=*" volumes: publisher_data: standby_data: external: true name: pg18-zdt_standby_data subscriber_v18: external: true name: pg18-zdt_subscriber_v18 ``` `max_active_replication_origins` is a new Postgres 18 GUC — split out from `max_replication_slots` so subscribers can size their replication-origin tracking independently. It defaults to 10 and is set at server start.[^18] Bring the cluster up and re-enable the subscription: ```bash docker compose up -d subscriber_v18 docker exec pg18-subscriber psql -U postgres -d shop \ -c "ALTER SUBSCRIPTION pg_createsubscriber_5_ ENABLE;" ``` ## Step 5: Sync sequences and cut over Logical replication does not replicate sequences in Postgres 18.[^15] Sequence-backed `IDENTITY` and `serial` column **values** flow through fine because they ride along as ordinary column data, but the sequence's internal pointer on the subscriber still points at the start value. The first insert directly against the new cluster will hand out an `id` that already exists — instant duplicate-key error. Sequence synchronization is on the roadmap for Postgres 19,[^16] but for 18 you have to do it manually. Generate a `setval()` script on the publisher and apply it on the subscriber **immediately before** the cutover, with a buffer to absorb any in-flight transactions: ```sql -- Run on publisher, capture output SELECT format( 'SELECT pg_catalog.setval(%L, %s, true);', schemaname || '.' || sequencename, COALESCE(last_value, 1) + 1000 ) FROM pg_sequences WHERE schemaname NOT IN ('pg_catalog','information_schema') ORDER BY schemaname, sequencename; ``` The `+ 1000` buffer is the conventional safety margin — it guarantees the subscriber's next sequence value is past whatever the publisher has handed out plus anything in flight during your cutover window. Apply the generated `setval()` statements on `pg18-subscriber`, then perform the cutover: ```bash # 1. Block writes on publisher (revoke INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE for app role, # or flip the load balancer to read-only). Keep reads alive. # 2. Wait for the subscription to drain to the publisher's current LSN: docker exec pg18-subscriber psql -U postgres -d shop -c " SELECT subname, latest_end_lsn FROM pg_stat_subscription;" docker exec pg17-publisher psql -U postgres -c "SELECT pg_current_wal_lsn();" # 3. When latest_end_lsn >= pg_current_wal_lsn, redirect application traffic # to port 5534 (the PG 18 cluster). # 4. Drop the subscription and the publisher's slot to clean up. docker exec pg18-subscriber psql -U postgres -d shop -c " ALTER SUBSCRIPTION pg_createsubscriber_5_ DISABLE; ALTER SUBSCRIPTION pg_createsubscriber_5_ SET (slot_name = NONE); DROP SUBSCRIPTION pg_createsubscriber_5_;" ``` The application is now writing to Postgres 18.3. ## Verification Two checks tell you the upgrade landed cleanly. First, every replicated table should be in the `r` (ready) state in `pg_subscription_rel`:[^17] ```sql SELECT srrelid::regclass AS table_name, srsubstate, srsublsn FROM pg_subscription_rel ORDER BY srrelid::regclass; ``` A `srsubstate` other than `r` on any row means a table is still synchronizing or stuck. Second, sequence pointers should be ahead of any existing IDs — `MAX(id)` on each table should be less than `nextval('')`. Insert a probe row on the new cluster and confirm no duplicate-key error. ## Troubleshooting **`pg_createsubscriber: error: target server must be shut down`** — the standby is still running. `docker compose stop standby` and rerun. The binary refuses to operate on a live cluster on purpose.[^1] **`max_active_replication_origins must be at least N`** — the new PG 18 GUC, split out from `max_replication_slots` in PG 18, defaults to 10 and is the per-subscriber equivalent of replication-slot accounting. Restart with the value bumped.[^18] **`subscription has tables in srsubstate = 's'` after pg_upgrade** — `pg_upgrade` requires every subscription table to be in `i` (init) or `r` (ready) state before it runs.[^14] Wait for the initial sync to finish before you upgrade. **`duplicate key value violates unique constraint` immediately after cutover** — sequences. Re-run the `setval()` script with a larger buffer; this is among the most common foot-guns in a logical-replication cutover.[^15] **Replication appears stuck, `pg_replication_slots.confirmed_flush_lsn` not advancing** — confirm the apply worker is alive on the subscriber (`pg_stat_subscription` should show a non-null `received_lsn`), and check `pg_stat_database_conflicts` on the publisher. If the publisher's WAL is filling up because the subscriber is far behind, raise `max_slot_wal_keep_size` or fix whatever is blocking apply (long-running transaction, lock conflict, missing primary key). ## Rollback Because the upgrade kept the original Postgres 17.9 primary running and accepting writes the entire time, **rollback is just a connection-string flip**. If something looks wrong on Postgres 18.3 within minutes of cutover, repoint the application back to port 5532. The PG 17.9 primary is still authoritative; the only data it doesn't have is whatever the application wrote against PG 18.3 after cutover. For a true bidirectional safety net, set up a reverse PG 18 → PG 17 logical subscription before cutover (publisher on the new cluster, subscriber on the old), so post-cutover writes flow back. That's worth the extra hour of setup for a critical OLTP workload. ## Next steps The same `pg_createsubscriber` workflow underpins blue-green deployments — set up a PG 18 replica, drain reads, cut over writes, decommission the old primary on a schedule rather than at 3 AM. Pair it with [PgBouncer or Supabase Supavisor in front of Postgres](/production-postgres-pooling-pgbouncer-supabase-supavisor-tutorial) so the connection switch is a pooler config reload instead of an application redeploy. If you need real-time UI events on top of this stack, [Postgres LISTEN/NOTIFY for live presence](/postgres-listen-notify-realtime-presence-tutorial) layers on top cleanly without any new replication. And if you want the entire Docker-Compose-based dev environment behind production-grade HTTPS, see the [Caddy reverse-proxy tutorial](/caddy-reverse-proxy-docker-compose-production-https-tutorial). [^1]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *pg_createsubscriber*. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/app-pgcreatesubscriber.html [^2]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *Chapter 29. Logical Replication — Upgrade*. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/logical-replication-upgrade.html [^3]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *pg_upgrade*. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/pgupgrade.html [^4]: PostgreSQL News, *PostgreSQL 18.3, 17.9, 16.13, 15.17, and 14.22 Released!* (February 26, 2026). https://www.postgresql.org/about/news/postgresql-183-179-1613-1517-and-1422-released-3246/ [^5]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *pg_createsubscriber* — `--all`, `--clean`, `--enable-two-phase` switches. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/app-pgcreatesubscriber.html [^6]: Docker, *Compose specification*. https://docs.docker.com/compose/ [^7]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *Chapter 29. Logical Replication*. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/logical-replication.html [^8]: pgPedia, *pg_createsubscriber*. https://pgpedia.info/p/pg_createsubscriber.html [^9]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *19.5. Write Ahead Log — wal_level*. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/runtime-config-wal.html [^10]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *19.5. Write Ahead Log* — automatic effective WAL-level promotion when a logical slot exists. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/runtime-config-wal.html [^11]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *pg_createsubscriber* — prerequisites for `max_replication_slots` and `max_wal_senders` on the source. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/app-pgcreatesubscriber.html [^12]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *pg_basebackup*. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/app-pgbasebackup.html [^13]: pgPedia, *pg_createsubscriber* — slot naming convention `pg_createsubscriber_%u_%x`. https://pgpedia.info/p/pg_createsubscriber.html [^14]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *Chapter 29.13. Upgrade* — pg_upgrade prerequisites for logical-replication clusters, including disabling subscriptions before upgrade. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/logical-replication-upgrade.html [^15]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *29.8. Restrictions* — sequences and large objects are not replicated. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/logical-replication-restrictions.html [^16]: depesz blog, *Waiting for PostgreSQL 19 — Sequence synchronization in logical replication* (November 2025). https://www.depesz.com/2025/11/11/waiting-for-postgresql-19-sequence-synchronization-in-logical-replication/ [^17]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *pg_subscription_rel system catalog*. https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/catalog-pg-subscription-rel.html [^18]: PostgreSQL 18 documentation, *19.6. Replication — `max_active_replication_origins`* (new in PG 18). https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/runtime-config-replication.html [^19]: PostgreSQL APT repository, *PostgreSQL Apt Repository* — serves all currently supported major versions. https://wiki.postgresql.org/wiki/Apt [^20]: docker-library/postgres GitHub PR / discussion — Postgres 18 image VOLUME change to `/var/lib/postgresql` to enable side-by-side major upgrades via `pg_upgrade --link`. https://github.com/docker-library/postgres/issues/37

#pgcreatesubscriber

Postgres 18 Zero-Downtime Upgrade: pg_createsubscriber 2026

Stay on the Nerd Track